The pace of change – is “online” a reflection of “urban”?

One of the challenges in achieving an integration of thinking between hackers and urbanists is the rate of change online. Will the massive experimentation currently underway on the internet continue at a pace, or settle down as norms are established and protocols emerge? Perhaps the same protocols that make it possible for people to live in cities. We sometimes call them “manners” or “cultural norms” and we know when they are being broken. Equally so, we call them street networks and we generally understand now to navigate them. We don’t all have to follow manners and streets but they offer a guide to behaviour and they make the difference between structured living and chaos.

How social networking protocols are established online will, in return, influence the social dynamic of future city living, perhaps as much as the efforts of planners and architects to structure social encounter by virtue of where we place things (buildings) and how we connect them together (streets, utilities and transport networks). This is because the people using online space and the people using urban space are the same people.

Online change is happening quickly yet cities evolved gradually. Up until 150 years ago there was, arguably, one kind of city: the grid city of trade. Social as well as economic trade. Edge to centre connections to create relationships between global and local movement, thus bringing local inhabitants into co-present relations with visitors from out of town.

Then, at the beginning of the 20th Century, came the Garden Cities, dividing and fragmenting the dense urbanism and diluting the transactions. After this came Modernism and a massive, experimental zoo of urban forms which, like the Garden Cities, divided, fragmented and diluted, this time with highways as well as landscapes.

Along the way, vitality was lost. Serendipity was lost. Cities underperformed. The common, slowly evolving historic thread was broken. Social networks in physical space were damaged to the point where some urban planning projects removed them almost entirely – people didn’t know their neighbours and, stuck in suburban sprawl without a car, had nowhere to go to make new connections. We have gone from a rich, mannered, cultured, protocoled world of serendipitous social relations to one where they no longer exist.

And then came online, providing a new source of social connectivity. However, the drawback has been that, at least at first, the search and discover nature of online social networking was poor – no easier to make new friends than to find them in the dark corners and elevated walkways of a failed public housing project.

Yet efforts continue to improve online encounter. Massive, experimental efforts that beg the question: is the internet doing for social networking (ie improving it) the reverse of what cities have done for relations in physical space (ie to damage them) Starting with febrile experimentation and underperformance, is online evolving towards consistency, protocols, intelligibility? And, most importantly, towards seredipity: the spark of humanity.

2 Comments on “The pace of change – is “online” a reflection of “urban”?”

  1. Pingback: Connectivity is only the beginning – networking is the goal | The power of the network

  2. Have cities always been serendipitous for all their inhabitants? Has social exclusion not always dogged cities and has their performance in holistic terms; impact on environment, health “sustainability”, food security, global competitiveness, ever been able to survive the impact of massive change or even of slow decay? I know some cities; Rome, London, Cairo have survived and had many incarnations and been the scene of imperialistic global resource empires; Survival at the expense of territories beyond their “footprint” Do we think computers and the internet will allow us to overcome human weakness, greed, ego, anger etc. and will we fare better in the future?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: